Choosing the Right Technology for Your Picking Strategy

Distribution Center Picking Technology

 

In Part I of our “Picking Strategy and Tech” series, I mentioned that Distribution Centers are going to have to deal with more diverse order profiles in this new digital age as wholesale orders are changing from Pallet size orders to case size orders.  Digital orders from the web will be more frequent with smaller number of items, because the customer is only ordering what they need and picking processes will need to be modified accordingly.  In this section, I am highlighting the possible picking technologies that will enable the new processes.

 

Picker to Item

Sending the picker to the items in the picking area is a traditional and the most common method of picking.  The material storage fixtures in the pick area range from Rack Shelving, Pallet or Case Flow Rack, and Bin Shelving.  To utilize the cube of the DC with high ceilings, Pick Modules and mezzanines are being used. To aid in picking the correct item and quantity for the order, technology has replaced the traditional pick list: RF Scanners, Pick-to-Light (pictured below) and Voice picking are the most popular technology to assist the picker.  The relatively new Pick-by-Vision, which incorporates augmented reality tech to help pickers, is another option as well.

Warehouse Pick to Light

Pick-to-Light

The main advantages for sending the picker to the item are when labor and square footage of the DC costs are lower relative to using other technologies.  Many pickers can be put into action to improve the throughput of the facility.

 

Item to Picker

More advance technologies are available that bring the item to the picker.  These technologies include Carousels, Mini-Loads, Automated Storage & Retrieval and Mobile storage systems.  Carousels are motorized bin shelving on rails that rotates the items stored on the shelving to a picking station.  Carousels include both horizontal and vertical direction and are sequenced to coordinate multiple carousels to improve picking through put.  Automatic Storage and Retrieval Systems (ASRS) are an integrated set of lifts that transverse through storage rack picking up containers and bringing them down to picking stations.  The classic ASRS is for pallet storage and retrieval.  When referring to case sizes or less than cases, Mini Loads are the technology used.  Another type of ‘Item to Picker’ technology are Mobile storage units, like automated guided vehicles they roll the storage device to a picking station highlighting the position on the shelf to pick the product from.

In most cases, these ‘item to picker’ technologies are coordinated in such a way to keep items in front of the pickers to minimize picker wait time and to maximize their productivity.  To achieve this, multiple sequenced pieces of technology are used, sometimes making the cost of the technology prohibitive for the productivity gains.

The main advantage for this type of technology to be deployed in DC’s is in areas where labor rates are higher and/or floor space is pricey enough to justify the expense.   The throughput restrictions of the technology, typically means that these ‘item to picker’ technology will not work for higher volume items.  Thus, the technology must be reviewed with the order profile to cost and through put justify the technology.  For example, many smaller lower volume items can increase their storage density in a pick area when using an ‘item to picker’ technology. Amazon bought Kiva Systems’ mobile storage units to own the technology for their smaller lower volume items like books; now known as Amazon Robotics.

 

Put to Order Technology

As discussed in the previous article, Batch Pick Technologies have a solid foundation in Digital Distribution centers where Web Promotional items generate a spike of demand for a few items.  These few items are waved together to generate a large quantity to be picked in bulk and sent to the ‘Put to Order’ technology to be divided up by order and combined with the other items of that order.

‘Put to Order’ technologies range from highly mechanized unit sorters to simple pallet/bin shelving (Put-Walls) to collect the multiple items being picked for an order.  Often the technology will use a light system that directs the associate to the order location to put a specific number of items in the outbound shipper.  For high volume facilities, a unit sorter (pictured below) which is typically a tilt-tray, Bombay or cross-belt type is used to marry up items from different pick zones across the facility.

Warehouse Unit Sorter

Unit Sorter

 

Medium volume facilities with many SKU’s which still have multiple pick zones, may use Put-Walls to combine the items from the multiple pick zones.  Lower volume facilities may combine ‘Item to Picker’ technologies with Put-Walls to capture all the items of the order.

 

Storage Technology to Compliment Picking

Digital Distribution centers are laid out in a multitude of ways to aid the technology being used for picking.   For ‘Picker to Item’ technologies, pick modules were mentioned as forward picking storage means to utilize the cube of the facility.  Other type modules may be used, for high volume items Very Narrow Aisle (VNA) storage should be used in conjunction with throw lines to peel off cases and send them to ‘Put to Order’ technologies. For higher to middle volume items, a Pick Module know as a Shave Tower can be used to move pallets of product to the tower so they can be picked to a conveyor line.

To utilize the cube of the facility when ‘Put to Order’ technology is being used, mezzanines are used so both the upper and lower levels are being productive.  Value added services and packing stations maybe positioned on one level while the ‘Put to Order’ technology is being used on the other level.

 

Robot or Cobot Technology

As discussed in the Zone Picking section, Cobots (Robots that move orders to people for them to pick the items to the orders) are finding their way into more Digital Distribution opportunities.  Because a person does not have to travel with the orders up and down aisles to perform the picking and only walk between Cobots to perform the picks in a defined zone, through-put and productivity improves 2-3x.

Currently Co-bots that are finding their way into digital distribution opportunities have been tote or carton carrying robots.  Pallet moving co-bots are making strides to become more prolific, as the smaller tote moving robots, are but they are limited by not being able to pass another robot in a standard 10’ aisle width and thus are limited to following pickers through a pick path, which defeats the purpose and eliminates the productivity gains of zone picking.  Some manufacturers of pallet moving robots are improving their laser guidance systems and in the near future they will be able to pass in 10’ aisles and their use in distribution will soar.

Another type of Robot used in distribution has a robotic arm associated to an automatic guided frame and picks items from open containers to the tote or shipping container.  The requirement on what can be picked by the robotic arm is restrictive and makes this an emerging technology.

Other Robots are being used in sortation applications and goods to person applications, making the use of robotics in distribution centers becoming more and more relevant.

 

Robotics Future in Distribution:

Distribution Industry Challenges:
  • Availability of Staff
  • High Churn
  • Increasing Labor Cost
Distribution Center Robot Hand
Robotic Technology Response:
  • Case Moving Robots (e-Com Applications)
  • Shelving Moving Robots (Goods to Person)
  • Pallet Moving Robots (Grocery, OEM, etc…)

 

Robotic adoption rate will increase 2x over the next 5 years. Extending to 70%+ of firms. (Source: MHI 2021, Annual Industry Report)

 

If you are in the market for a robot picker, we highly recommend Locus Robotics as they have done fantastically by our clients.  Drop us a line, and we’ll chat – and while we like robots, we don’t fancy chatbots – about the increase in ROI we’ve seen at our customer sites.

This post was written by:

Richard Barnes Tryon Solutions
Richard Barnes Senior Project Manager  Richard is a supply chain expert and master black belt with extensive leadership experience and a strong background in applying people, process and technology to streamline supply chain operations. You can reach him at: richard.barnes[at]tryonsolutions[dot]com

Recommended Content

A Big Question for Multi-Warehouse WMS Implementations

  The strategic planning stage is obviously critical for WMS implementations, and one commonly glossed over aspect is multi-warehouse configurations.  The implementation team is focused on the success of the first site with both budget and timeline crunches in...

Key WMS Reports & Dashboards for a Warehouse or Distribution Center

  Your company has taken an important step towards the future by investing in warehouse management software. One of the major drivers behind this may have included increasing the operational efficiency of both labor and physical space by harnessing the real-time...

We Saw Robot Picking in Action…

    An efficient operation is no longer a “nice to have” in this era of labor shortages and ruthless competition.  We recently toured the warehouse of a large electronics company located in the Southern United States that saved 35,000 US dollars a month...

Top Five Warehouse Management System KPIs

  How do we know if our warehouse or distribution center is running as expeditiously as possible?  Accounting department touts great numbers, warehouse personnel are clearly working hard, and everything “looks and feels” right, so isn’t that good enough?  You...